I will say, I have been at this for about 5 weeks and IT IS A GRIND. That said I am realizing sleep compression/restriction and hygiene is only one piece of the puzzle, it’s the behavioral part of CBT, the cognitive part is the other arguably bigger (and more difficult) part. I have tried this on my own in the past and it did not work, but thankfully I found a practitioner that can help me that is also covered by my health care program.
It is very nuanced…I tried one of the sleep apps (Sleep Reset) and the idea and framework was there but I could tell they were following a very set program and schedule with very little grey area IE after two weeks do this after three weeks do this. Well my body and mind (like many others I am sure) didn’t want to follow that script. Finding an actual professional has been the lynch pin for me. To be able to hear simple things like “this part is normal” or “you are in the worse before better stage” and “lots of other experience this” helped me stick with it where I would have given up otherwise. Then of course she has given me tools to address specific things, like my early morning waking.
Honestly I feel like basic sleep hygiene is kind of low hanging fruit that probably works well for folks who already sleep “ok” and it can improve on that. For me it was a bit of a frustration to try all of those somewhat easy things and not get results, I then realized that simply going to bed and waking up at the same time every day and avoiding blue light etc wasn’t going to un layer 10 years of insomnia.
Anyway, I am by no means out of the woods yet but have been doing better in the last 3-4 days, and that’s after 4 weeks of sleep restrictions and 4 one on one appointments with my sleep therapist. I liken it to physiotherapy or an exercise routine, the results are slow and take work, but it will be worth it in the end.
Good luck